How to Negotiate Better Rates When Booking Freight - OTR Solutions

How to Negotiate Better Rates When Booking Freight

Last Updated on: October 28, 2024

Running a trucking business means constantly balancing costs with profits, and one of the most effective ways to increase revenue isn’t just by hauling more loads—it’s by negotiating better lane rates for the loads you already run.

 

At OTR Solutions, we believe one of the most important steps to operating a successful business is to maximize the value of each mile driven. Hauling more freight alone isn’t always the answer—hauling freight at higher rates with smarter planning can be.

 

Below are actionable strategies to help you negotiate better rates so that you increase revenue without significantly increasing costs.

How to Negotiate Better Rates

1. Monitor Average Lane Rates in Real Time

Knowing the average rate for the lanes you operate in is one of the easiest ways to justify a rate increase. If the load you’re booking offers less than the lane’s average, use that information to negotiate a higher rate with the broker. This demonstrates that you are well-informed about the market.

Pro tip: Using tools like DAT’s load board, which shows average lane rates alongside posted rates, takes the guesswork out of pricing and makes it easier to negotiate. If a broker knows that you’re informed, they are more likely to meet or exceed the average rate to secure your service.

Example: If a lane typically averages $2.50 per mile and the broker offers you $2.20 per mile, politely explain the market trend and request an increase. Even a bump of $0.10 to $0.15 per mile can have a significant cumulative impact.

2. Build and Leverage Your Reputation

Brokers value consistency and reliability. A well-established carrier with a strong safety score (SMS data) and a track record of on-time deliveries has leverage. If your trucking business has these attributes, you can confidently ask for an additional $50–$100 per load to reflect your reliability and professionalism.

Tip: Highlight any recent safety milestones or your MC’s clean inspection history when negotiating. Carriers with excellent safety scores help brokers reduce their risk and provide peace of mind that the freight will arrive on time and intact. This can justify premium rates over carriers with less predictable records.

However, consistency goes both ways. If your business has had issues—like missed deadlines or poor communication—brokers will track these and may be reluctant to offer higher rates in the future. Every load you complete successfully builds trust and opens doors to better negotiating power.

3. Don’t Underestimate the Power of Small Increases

Even seemingly small increases—like an extra $50 per load—can make a significant difference over time.

Example:

· 8 loads per month x 12 months = 96 loads per year

· $50 extra per load = $4,800 extra annually

That’s nearly $5,000 in additional income without increasing expenses. Small increases add up fast when applied consistently across all your loads.

4. Plan Your Trips to Avoid Empty Miles

Driving non-revenue miles (or “deadhead miles”) erodes your profit margin. Carefully planning your routes ensures you don’t haul freight to remote areas without a follow-up load lined up.

Pro tip: Loads that deliver to rural or less populated areas may offer higher pay because they are harder to cover. But if the payout from these loads doesn’t justify the cost of empty miles or repositioning to a better freight lane, they may not be worth it.

For example, during produce season (spring to early summer), lane rates out of Florida increase because of heightened demand. However, getting loads into Florida can be challenging. A well-planned round trip—factoring in the return route—ensures your business remains profitable even if part of the trip involves deadhead miles.

5. Sell Your Business’s Strengths to the Broker

When negotiating, make sure brokers know the advantages of working with your trucking business. Some selling points that can secure higher rates include:

· Safety rating: A good safety score reduces risk for brokers.

· Specialized equipment: If your truck is equipped with special features (like temperature-controlled trailers), it increases the value of the load and justifies a higher rate.

· Quick delivery capabilities: If you can reliably deliver ahead of schedule, this is a strong selling point—especially for time-sensitive freight.

Even if the load seems straightforward, pointing out these details creates the perception that the broker is working with a premium carrier who deserves more than the posted rate.

Final Thoughts

Negotiating better trucking rates isn’t just about making more money—it’s about running a smarter, more efficient business. Every dollar you secure above the posted rate improves your bottom line, especially when operating expenses stay constant.

The next time a broker offers a load, don’t just accept the first offer—negotiate for what makes sense for your business. Armed with real-time data, a proven track record, and careful trip planning, you can get more value from every mile you drive.

At OTR Solutions, we encourage you to take control of your business’s financial success by maximizing your efforts. Remember, brokers don’t always offer the highest rates upfront—but you have the power to ask for more and make every load count.

Connect with a Representative